IMPACT OF MICRO-FINANCE BANKS ON SMEs IN NIGERIA
1.1 Background to the Study
In Nigeria, credit has been recognized as an essential tool for promoting small and Micro Enterprises (SMEs). About 70 percent of the population is engaged in the informal sector or in agricultural production. The Federal and State governments have recognized that for sustainable growth and development, the financial empowerment of the people is vital. If this growth strategy is adopted and the latent entrepreneurial capabilities of this large segment of the people is sufficiently stimulated and sustained, then positive multipliers will be felt throughout the economy. To give effect to these aspirations various policies have been instituted over time by the Federal Government to improve rural and urban enterprise production capabilities (Olaitan 2006)
Small Business Enterprise (SBE) transformation is all about seeking to bring about improvement in the living condition of the farmer, the artisan, the tenant and the landless within the simple and rustic economies of the country-sides and urban slums. The basis for employment generation and entrepreneurship development in the country, therefore, is to enhance the improvement of the living condition of the people (Mustapha, 2009).
The Micro business entrepreneurs lack the necessary financial services, especially credit from the commercial banks; this is because they are considered not credit worthy. Consequently they depended on families, friends and other informal sources of funds to finance their businesses.
Successive governments have come up with special programs, whose principal targets are the overall empowerment of low income earners in urban centers. These programmes range from Agricultural Development Projects (ADPs), the establishment of Agricultural Credit Banks to Better Life Programme for Rural Women and the like. Unfortunately most of the programmes failed to achieve the desired result. That led to the emergence of microfinance banks which aimed at extending credits to micro enterprises and encouraging entrepreneurship.
The Nigerian microfinance industry has come a long way; it boasts of all the four well-known models in the industry. A CBN study identified, as of 2001, 160 registered MFIs in Nigeria with aggregate savings wo rth N99.4 million and outstanding credit of N649.6 million, indicating huge business transactions in the sector (Anyanwu, 2004). Institutional structures for the provision of micro credit vary and may be any of the following: government or public sector-oriented, NGO supported, traditional or a mixture of two or more of these.
Lagos state, with a population of about 15 million (2006 census report) of which about two -thirds of the residents are poor and struggling for survival in the face of high rate of unemployment, the need for micro finance support cannot be over emphasis. Most of these people in Lagos are dependent on micro and small-scale farming and off-farm enterprises for their livelihood. As such, their entrepreneurial contributions are strategic to the Nigerian economic development and growth has great potential to contribute to income generation and poverty alleviation.
In the light of the foregoing, this study is conducted to examine the impact of microfinance banks on Micro Business Enterprises (SBE) in Nigeria.1.2 Statement of Problem
One of the challenges of micro financing in Nigeria at present is how to the Micro Finance Institutions (MFI) can reach a greater number of small scale business enterpreneurs. The CBN survey indicated that their client base was about 600,000 in 2001, and there were indications that they may not be above 1.5 million in 2003. The existing microfinance banks in Nigeria serves less than 1 million people out of 40 million potential people that need the service (CBN, 2005).
Also, the aggregate micro credit facilities in Nigeria, account for about 0.2 percent of GDP and less than one percent of total credit to the economy. The effect of not appropriately addressing this situation would further accentuate poverty and slow down growth and development of SMEs in the country.
The Microfinance Banks replaced the ailing Community Banks created by former military head of state General Ibrahim Babangida but was soon caught in the throes of an inefficient Nigerian economic system. This laudable concept has been hijacked by money bags; it has been caught by bureaucracy of the Nigerian politics and economics. The concept of micro financing is presently being misapplied. The CBN directs that every microfinance bank should have a minimum reserve of not less than N20 million, while at the same time directing that the NDIC insures each depositor for a maximum N100,000.00 regardless of the amount of money invested.
These requirements takes the microfinance industry out of the reach of the people it was intended to serve; the very poor. While at the same time it discourages prospective investors because their funds are not sufficiently secured. It is interesting to know that the CBN does not regulate interest rates charged by microfinance banks; so with N20m tied up in the CBN vaults as legal reserve ratio, high cost of incorporation of business ventures; taxes, approvals, rents, salaries etc the operators hardly have enough left to commence operations.
Having failed to capture its target market, Microfinance banks in the country are now trying to compete with full fledged banks but are grossly lacking in the most important aspect of its operations; that is raising funds from depositors and getting prospective clients to shed their phobia for bank loans for fear of exorbitant interest rates charged and hidden bank charges.
According to Akindutire,(2008) Operators of microfinance banks believe it is a short cut to owning a bank without going through the rigours of procuring a banking license or paying the over N250m CBN deposit required to start a banking business. It is commonplace to find a microfinance bank taking out expensive paid adverts and expensive corporate imaging in the hope that it will open them up to the market.
On the contrary it extrapolated their problems. For instance what would a microfinance bank be doing at Adeola Odeku or Ikoyi? When the target market is at Okokomaiko, Mile 2, or all other places where you can find an akara, plantain (boli) seller, recharge card seller, okada rider e.t.c instead microfinance banks are competing for corporate accounts they want to have salary accounts for government parastatal, or finance petroleum marketing industries, consequently you will find them in suits, chauffeur driven in state of the art cars.
Against the backdrop of the foregoing problems, this study will examine the micro finance institutions and their impact on small scale businesses in Nigeria.1.3 Objectives of Study
The primary objective of this study shall be to examine the impact of micro finance bank on the Growth and development of Micro Business Enterprises in Nigeria and Lagos in particular. Other salient objectives will include;
i. To determine the relationship between Micro finance banks and Small Business Entrepreneurs in Nigeria.
ii. To examine the challenges of micro financing in Nigeria
iii. To identify the impact of lack of financial support on small scale businesses
iv. To suggest means by which micro finance institutions
can be more responsive to Small business needs in Nigeria
1.4 Research Questions
The following research questions shall guide the study;
i. what is the relationship between micro finance Banks and small business enterprises in Nigeria?
ii. What are the challenges of Micro Finance in Nigeria?
iii. What are the effects of lack of financial support on Small business?
iv. How can micro Finance institutions be responsive to small business enterprises demands?
1.5 Research hypotheses
The following hypotheses will be tested in the study;
Ho: There is no relationship between Micro finance Banks
and Small Business Enterprises in Nigeria
Hi: There is a relationship between Micro finance Banks and
Small Business Enterprises in Nigeria
Ho: Micro finance banks do not encourage small business
owners in Lagos
Hi; Micro finance banks do not encourage small business
owners in Lagos
1.6 Significance of the Study
Robust economic growth cannot be achieved without putting in place well focused programmes to reduce poverty through empowering the people by increasing their access to factors of production, especially credit. The latent capacity of the poor entrepreneurs would be significantly enhanced through the provision of microfinance services to enable them engage in economic activities and be more self-reliant; increase employment opportunities, enhance household income, and create wealth.
However, the lack of required financial support from the microfinance banks to Micro Business operators in Lagos state has become a major concern in Nigeria. Hence, this study shall be relevant to policy makers in the areas of finding out the impact of micro financing on the small scale investors. Also, this study shall enhance further research in the subject area.
1.7 Scope and Limitations of the Study
The scope of the study shall cover micro finance banks and micro business entrepreneurs in Lagos state metropolis. However, owing to shortage of literature and financial data, raw data shall be generated from selected small business operators in Ojo local government area of Lagos state.
1.8 Research Methodology
The study shall employ the survey research method in the process of data collection. The method entails identifying population of study and collection of data through questionnaire administration.
Population of Study
The population of study shall comprise of Small Business Entrepreneurs in Ojo local government area of Lagos state. The population size is at about 420 Micro and Small Businesses Entrepreneurs which largely includes owners of supermarkets, electronic shops, pharmacies, Business centers/ cyber cafes, restaurants, barbing and hair dressing salons, pure water companies and paint companies in the metropolis.
A sample size of 110 respondents was drawn from the study population. The constitution of the sample was as follows;
The study shall adopt the stratified random sampling technique. The method entails grouping respondents into strata on the bases of common characteristics which in this case is the industrial affiliation. After the grouping, the simple random sampling technique is then applied to select the required sample size
Data Collection Instrument
Data collection will be done through the questionnaire method. The questionnaire was structured into section A and B with close ended questions. Section A shall generate information on respondents’ bio-data while, section B, will elicits information on respondents perception of the impact of Microfinance Banks on small business enterprises in Lagos State.
The questionnaire is in a close ended format which allowed the respondents to offer their views according to the Lickert scale of responses as follows;
SA – Strongly Agreed
A - Agreed
U - Undecided
SD – Strongly Disagreed
Administration of the Instrument
To foster quick response to the questionnaire, the researcher will personally administered the questionnaires to the respondents. The effort enable the researcher to clear some of the items contain in the instrument with the respondents while, at the same time, respondent attention were drawn to some items yet to be filled.
Method of Data Analysis
All data collected shall be analyzed using statistical tools such as frequency distribution table, percentages, and chi-square analysis for testing the formulated hypotheses.
X2 = ∑(O-E)2
df (degree of freedom)= N-1
X2 = Chi-square calculated value.
O = Observed frequency
E = Expected frequency which is derived by
df = Degree of freedom
N = Number of Observation
∞ = level of significant (5%)
1.9 Definition of Key Terms
Small Scale Business: A small business is a business that is privately owned and operated, with a small number of employees and relatively low volume of sales
Micro Finance: Flexible structures and processes by which financial services are delivered to micro entrepreneurs
Micro Finance Banks (MFB): Special banks dedicated to
Entrepreneur: The proprietor or owner of a small business enterprise.
Aluko, M., Odugbesan, O., Gbadamosi, G. & Osuagwu, L. 2004. Business policy and strategy. Lagos: Longman Nigeria Plc.
Acharya, S.N. (1981) "Perspectives and problems of development in
Sub-Saharan Africa", World Development,
Aftab, K. and E. Rahim (1989) "Barriers to the growth of informal
sector firms: a case study", Journal of Development Studies, 25(4).
Akinduntire G.A. (1983) "Financing small-scale enterprises",
Central Bank of Nigeria Bulletin, 8(2).
Box, R. de la (1983) "Policies for financing of small-scale industries:
Kenyan experience", in N. Molenaar, M.S. El-Namaki and M.P. Van Dijk (eds) Small-Scale Industries Promotion in Developing Countries, The Netherlands.
Chenery, H. et al. (1974) Redistribution with Growth, Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Chiber, R. and J. Wilton, (1986). “Macroeconomic Policies and
Agricultural Performance in Developing Countries”. Finance & Development, 23(3):pp. 6-9.
Daniel, P., R.H. Green and M. Lipton (1985) "A strategy for the
rural poor", Journal of Development Planning, 15, New York: United Nations.
Ekpenyong, D.B. (1982) "Problems of small businesses and why
they fail", Journal of General Studies, Bayero University, Jos, 3(1).
International Labour Organization (1973) "Sharing in development:
a programme of employment, equity and growth in the Philippines", Geneva: ILO.
Kilby, P. (1969) Industrialization in an Open Economy: Nigeria
1945-66, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. (1975) "Manufacturing in colonial Africa", in Colonialism in Africa 1969-78, Vol. 4, London: Cambridge University Press.
Ojo, A.T. (1976) The Nigerian Financial System, Ibadan. (1984)
Banking in Nigeria, Graham Burn.
Osuagwu, L. 2001. An empirical evaluation of the corporate
strategies of Nigerian companies. Journal of African Business, 2(2), 45-75.
Olofin, S. (1990) "The prospects for an outward-looking
industrialization strategy under adjustment in Sub-Saharan Africa", a paper presented at the World Bank Africa Economic Issues Conference, held in Nairobi, 4-7 June.
Oshima, H.T. 91962) "A strategy for Asian development", Economic
Development and Cultural Change, 10(3).
Appleyard, D. R. and A. J. Field, JR, (1998). International Economics. © Irwin/McGraw-Hill Boston.